Compare

Every way to get your photos out of iCloud, compared.

There’s more than one way to keep your own copy of an iCloud Photos library. Here’s an honest look at each, and when it’s the right choice.

PhotoCargo and Photos’ own export

Photos › File › Export › Export Unmodified Original is built into every Mac and a fine choice for a few hundred photos.

PhotoCargo and Photos’ own exportPhotoCargoPhotos › Export Unmodified Original
Full-resolution originals
Live Photo videos and RAW files
Checks every copy with a checksum
Pauses and resumes after interruptions
Copies to two drives at once
Copies only what’s new next time

PhotoCargo

Best for
Large libraries, repeat backups, two drives, and anyone who wants proof that every file arrived intact.
How
Choose selected photos, a date range or the whole library, pick one or two APFS drives, then Copy and Verify. Originals download from iCloud as needed.
Watch out for
Mac only, macOS Tahoe 26 or later, APFS drives. The free version copies up to 10 new items per transfer; Unlimited is a one-time purchase.

Read the guide

Photos › Export Unmodified Original

Best for
A few hundred photos you want as originals, right now.
How
Select photos in Photos, choose File › Export › Export Unmodified Original, then choose a folder.
Watch out for
Nothing checks the exported files, an interrupted export starts over, and there’s no built-in way to export only what’s new since last time.

Read the guide

Photos › Export (edited versions)

Best for
Sharing finished pictures with your edits applied.
How
Select photos, choose File › Export › Export Photos, and pick a format and size.
Watch out for
These are rendered copies, not originals. Original-quality data and Live Photo videos may not be included.

Read the guide

iCloud.com in a web browser

Best for
Grabbing a few photos from a computer that isn’t yours.
How
Sign in at iCloud.com, open Photos, select items and download them.
Watch out for
Selecting and downloading a large library in a browser is impractical, and nothing verifies or resumes the downloads.

Read the guide

Apple’s “Request a copy of your data”

Best for
A one-time export of everything in your Apple Account.
How
At privacy.apple.com, request a copy of your iCloud Photos. Apple prepares the files and notifies you when they’re ready to download.
Watch out for
It can take time, you have 14 days to download it, it isn’t available everywhere, and it can’t be limited to a date range or kept up to date.

Read the guide

Move the Photos library to an external drive

Best for
A library too big for your Mac that you still want to browse and edit in Photos.
How
Quit Photos, drag Photos Library from your Pictures folder to an APFS or Mac OS Extended (Journaled) drive, open it there and make it your System Photo Library.
Watch out for
It’s still a single copy managed by Photos, not a backup. The drive must stay connected, it can’t be a Time Machine drive, and with Optimize Mac Storage the originals may still be only in iCloud.

Read the guide

Time Machine

Best for
Backing up your whole Mac, including the Photos library package.
How
Back up the Mac to an external drive with Time Machine.
Watch out for
Time Machine backs up what’s stored on your Mac. With Optimize Mac Storage, many originals exist only in iCloud, so they may not be in the backup.

Read the guide

Command-line tools (icloudpd, osxphotos)

Best for
People comfortable with Terminal who want scripted, repeatable exports.
How
Install the tool, then run it with a destination folder on your drive. osxphotos exports from the Photos library on your Mac; icloudpd signs in to your Apple Account and downloads from iCloud.
Watch out for
Setup, two-factor sign-in and error messages all happen in a terminal. There’s no interface to review what will be copied, and verification depends on the options you pass.

Read the guide

The short version

For a handful of photos, use Photos’ own export. For a whole library, especially one stored in iCloud with Optimize Mac Storage on, use a tool that downloads originals as needed, verifies every file and can resume. That’s what PhotoCargo is for.

PhotoCargo

Your iCloud photos and videos. Your drive. Verified.

PhotoCargo for Mac is free to download on the Mac App Store, with every feature included.

macOS Tahoe 26 or later · APFS-formatted drives